Bitter Battle with BofA

After 26 years as a good and fully satisfied customer I find myself caught in an extended ‘he said; she said’ back-and-forth battle with Bank of America. Though it’s not what he (let alone she) said, but what they claim I did despite clear and obvious evidence I didn’t. In fact, couldn’t have.

What’s aggravating is that the investigators don’t appear to be actually investigating. They won’t contact me or the merchant, so I’m not sure quite what they’re investigating.

This has been going on all summer, since late May…

May 26: My first inkling is an email from BofA asking about suspicious credit card activity. Did I authorize this? It was for $4620.50 for a company I’d never heard of, so I clicked No. That took me to a webpage that essentially said, okay, we’ll cancel the transaction, now call us to change your card.

Which I did, and they did, and then I had to go through past bills to see what sites used that card so I could change to the new card when it arrived. I also gave some thought as to how my card info got into someone’s hands. For years, I’ve only used that card online, so the possibilities are limited.

§

The email/text thing happens from time to time, usually when I buy something different enough to trigger their watchdog algorithms. You may have experienced it yourself. In such cases, I did buy the thing, so I click Yes, and all’s well.

I only experienced stolen credit card information once. It was back when it was common to hand the card to a cashier for them to process. I’m pretty sure a new hire at the liquor store I frequented made a copy of my card number and later tried to use it.

[That store clearly had trouble getting good help. The workers there were young, disaffected, and focused on their phones. Any interaction, even paying for your purchase, they treated as an interruption.]

Then as now, BofA contacted me about a suspicious transaction. I clicked No, and then called them about canceling the card and getting a new one issued. That went smooth as silk, a new card soon arrived, and I wasn’t charged for the fraudulent transaction.

I thought highly of BofA because of how painless the experience was.

And thankful they had my back.

Oh, how the times have changed.

§

Everything seemed okay. BofA removed the charge (on May 28), I got the new card, I changed it on the sites I’d registered it with for auto-payments, and I deleted my account from one site I was suspicious about.

I won’t name names (other than BofA, obviously), but I’d recently registered my profile info, including CC number, on a site that had been recommended by an earnest and I’m quite sure genuine YouTuber. I have no reason, let alone a good one, to doubt the site; as far as I can tell, it’s 100% legit. I’m going only by the coincidence of timing. And that nearly all the other sites that know that card number are major sites (e.g. Amazon).

I’d ordered some goods from the site in question before, and they were delivered (and exactly what was ordered). But that first time I used the card in passing and didn’t create a profile or have them save the info. Months later, ordering from them again, I decided I’d like return again, so I created a profile to make things easier. Shortly thereafter, this all happened.

But, as in the first time, it appeared to end well.

§

July 9: I get a letter from BofA saying they are “unable to approve” my claim. The reason they give is:

We confirmed the merchandise was shipped or service(s) was provided to an address listed on our account.

Grammar aside, that’s simply not true. As it will turn out, it couldn’t be true because no actual merchandise or service(s) ever existed. The fraudsters created the whole thing electronically using stolen information.

I called BofA immediately and protested. The call taker said they could resubmit the claim for further consideration. I said please do!

With the letter, I’d gotten documentation from BofA of the alleged transaction, and I noticed a number of interesting points:

Firstly, the invoice number was #000001. That’s weird. Invoice numbers are based on the merchant, not the client, otherwise a merchant would end up with lots of invoices numbered #000001. It’s as if the merchant was brand new.

Secondly, the order was for “siding” — no other description, no details.

Thirdly, while my name and street address and email were under “Customer”, there was no shipping info of any kind. In particular, no delivery date.

[The documentation BofA sent me is apparently some sort of photocopy of printouts. They have a beige background with slightly darker beige type. And smaller than the page, so very difficult to read. I had to scan them and use a photo editor to crank up the contrast.]

When I called BofA I pointed out that I lived in a condo and not only wouldn’t order “siding” but aren’t allowed to have anything to do with the siding here.

§

August 20: I get essentially the same letter from BofA:

We confirmed the merchandise was shipped or service(s) was provided to an address listed on our account.

Why does it take them so long to respond? Their assertion isn’t true, so I called again, spoke to a call taker again, and re-re-submitted my claim.

I’ll say this: the call takers are all very nice and sympathetic. Unfortunately, they can’t really do anything but pass on information, and the people making the decisions refuse to communicate with me. It feels like malfeasance.

I think it was this time the call taker suggested it might be helpful to contact the merchant. I took that under advisement. For a severe introvert, cold-calling a company to ask about a supposed transaction made in your name is a bit intimidating. My self-defeating thought was, “They probably consider that proprietary information and could even be offended I dared to ask.”

As it turns out, this ended up being one of the nicer parts of the story.

§

September 7: After looking at their website, I decide to use their contact page to email them. I wondered if I should actually drive out to their location (about 100 miles outside the cities), if it would be more effective to ask in person, but thought I’d try email first.

The website also provided the phone numbers for the CEO and CFO, so I built up my courage and, getting their voicemail in both cases, left messages for both.

September 8: While shopping at Target, my phone rings, and it’s the CFO from the merchant I supposedly ordered siding from. He’s really nice. He tells me I’m not the first one who experienced this. Someone else in the Twin Cities called him back in July about almost the exact same thing (and as he recalled, about the same charge, and he thought it was a BofA card to boot).

They’re a small construction company about 100 miles north of the cities. It seems their identity was stolen and used to create fraudulent transactions against stolen credit card info. He’s reported this to his local police, and there was a police report on file, and the officer had even provided his phone number.

I also got a call from the CEO, who at that point was just following up, but she was very  nice, too. Yet another life lesson about not letting self-defeating fears stop you from trying.

They recommended I fill out a police report with my local police, which I did the next day. That was interesting. I’ve seen it on TV many times. Now I’ve lived it.

I called BofA and provided all this info, including the police report numbers and phone numbers of all parties. And that the merchant was happy to explain the situation.

§

October 8: I get yet another rejection letter from BofA. This time they’ve gotten a bit terse:

The merchant provided documentation confirming you received the merchandise or service.

Which is physically impossible. I’ve spoken to the merchant; the BofA clearly has not. I don’t know what playbook they’re operating out of, but something is rotten in Denmark.

I called and had them resubmit once again, but at this point I’m not sure what to do. Should I get a lawyer and try to sue them? It’s all very distressing and depressing, and it put a dark cloud over my summer and fall.

I thought we were finally done, especially after providing the merchant and police info, but what does it take?

§

Let’s summarize:

  • BofA recognized this as a suspicious transaction when it happened.
  • I immediately affirmed it wasn’t my doing.
  • No shipping info on supposed order (e.g. delivery date).
  • No details on what was ordered, just “siding”.
  • Merchant confirms they were not involved; identity stolen.
  • Electronic fraud, no actual merchandise or service(s).
  • Trouble-free customer for 26 years, why would I do this?

Needless to say I am a very unhappy customer. They put the charge back on my credit card, so at the least I’m being charged (noticeable) interest on it. So far the minimum payment has been below whatever charges I put on the card that month, so in my mind I’m paying only for that.

But assuming I get BofA to do the right thing, it’s going to be a tangle trying to sort out the interest charges. And if they refuse to recognize that I had nothing to do with this, and I’m forced to pay this charge, then I think I’d have no choice but to find a lawyer and try to sue them.

[In my fantasies, it becomes a jury trial, and the jury is very sympathetic and unhappy with giant corporations, so they award a huge amount in punitive damages. Enough to truly spank BofA. High fantasy, for sure, but if it did happen, I’d donate every penny to dog charities.]

§ §

The irony is that, back in the day, the Hippies really hated Bank of America because they saw it as a symbol of Big Corporate Money and Greed. I’m not much of a causes kinda guy and mostly ignored all that. I’ve had two of their credit cards for 26 years, so obviously I am, or at least was, fine with them.

It’s only now that I’m like, “Fuck Bank of America!” Took only, what, fifty years to catch up to my former crowd? I’m typically a slow adapter, but this one is a record, I think.

Stay steady, my friends! Go forth and spread beauty and light.

∇

About Wyrd Smythe

Unknown's avatar
The canonical fool on the hill watching the sunset and the rotation of the planet and thinking what he imagines are large thoughts. View all posts by Wyrd Smythe

16 responses to “Bitter Battle with BofA”

  • Paul Torek's avatar Paul Torek

    May your dog charities prosper!

  • Bookstooge's avatar Bookstooge

    Good luck. My wife had BofA when we got married and it was a huge pain to even close her account with them.

    Sorry you are having to deal with this.

  • SelfAwarePatterns's avatar SelfAwarePatterns

    Sorry to hear about this. I had my own issues with them a few years ago. I’ve had a credit card with them for decades. One day I got an email welcoming me to my new BofA checking account, which I never signed up for.

    I immediately called them and informed them it was fraud. I was transferred, and then transferred again and again, and then landed in a queue with elevator music, then disconnected. Long story short, it took a couple of days to finally reach the fraud division and file a claim, and then got a claim number. The lady informed me that my identity had to be stolen, because their systems were too secure to let anyone in otherwise.

    The checking account immediately disappeared from my online account, but I continued getting paper statements on it for months. Trying to call in again to check on my claim was a lost cause. Similar to your experience, everyone was polite, but getting actual results seemed to be impossible. Their people aren’t the problem. It’s their system which is rotten.

    At least it made me wake up to how lax my security was with many of my online accounts. I went on a password hardening spree, and turned on MFA everywhere I could. I actually thought BofA had default MFA for logins from unfamiliar devices, but discovered that they didn’t. It’s now set for every login.

    I used to use my BofA card as my primary. Now it’s only a backup, which I keep because I don’t want to unfreeze my credit reports to apply for another backup somewhere else. But seeing your case is making me wonder if it’s not smarter to just kill it.

    • Wyrd Smythe's avatar Wyrd Smythe

      Wow. I’m clearly not alone. I wonder if they’re unique in this or if it’s endemic to the industry. So far, my actual bank has always been wonderful. No complaints there. If anything, kudos for them.

      I’m not sure what I’ll do when this is resolved. Even if they fix things, I think I’m done letting them make money off my purchases. I’ll either transfer the sites using those cards to my bank card or maybe look into using PayPal or other service as a single point of distribution. But now I have to sit down and go through a few years of bills from both cards to see where I’ve used the cards.

      Might be funny to keep the cards but remove them from every site and never use them except once a year to purchase something low in price just to force them to keep the cards alive and spend a few cents billing me.

      Or just cancel the cards and move on. Really depends on how this resolves. I might end up in the position of having to either [A] bite the damn bullet, [B] try to sue BofA, [C] see if the local news would be interested in this story (especially since there is apparently another similar victim in the Twin Cities metro area). I’m really hoping it doesn’t end up being [A]. 😨😖

      • SelfAwarePatterns's avatar SelfAwarePatterns

        On the industry, I can tell you that in my subsequent hardening phase, I needed to remove an old number from my Chase profile, and their customer service was far better. Unfortunately their savings accounts, CD, and investment products are poor.

        I keep my checking with them because I’ve had it forever and have a ton of stuff tied it. But I only keep limited funds there, reasoning that if I’m ever a victim of wire fraud or something similar, that’s where it would be, and any losses would be bad but manageable.

        One thing I now do, inspired by the Paypal default, is have all money accounts email me on every transaction, bar none. The idea is to know about anything suspicious ASAP, and just keep up overall awareness of what’s happening in them.

        $4600 is a bad amount. I wonder if it’s enough to make a lawsuit worth it. It definitely isn’t an amount I would want to just eat. You could also try filing a case with the CFPB or FTC. Not sure how functional they are right now, but still might be worth a shot.

        For my BofA card, I have a storage unit I pay for monthly that’s still on it. It’s basically there to keep them from auto-retiring the account. Every so often something I long ago forgot about hits it, like my stupid SiriusXM subscription, which is now canceled. Although just having the account can be a risk, but maybe not too much if you’re not using the card number widely.

      • Wyrd Smythe's avatar Wyrd Smythe

        That’s a good idea about notifications on everything. Do you also get copied on regular CC transactions you made yourself? Interesting idea about a “cut out” bank account just for paying bills. I think I’ll look into that, too.

        And thanks for reminding me about looking into various agencies, Federal or otherwise, that might help. Maybe add the BBB to that list. Definitely something to check out. (And probably much easier than trying to get the local news interested. The only downside being the state of the Feds these days.)

        I lead a sufficiently quiet life that the CC I use normally (from my bank) only gets used in a dozen or so places. Groceries, gas, some frequented restaurants, and various local places such as auto shops and whatnot. The card is never out of my hands in those places (except at restaurants). Everyone has payment terminals now (and so do some restaurants). That’s the weirder aspect of this: I’m really wondering how the scammers got that CC info.

      • SelfAwarePatterns's avatar SelfAwarePatterns

        On emails, I have it set for everything. If I buy a drink out of the office vending machine (which has become stupidly expensive BTW), there’s usually an email about it waiting for me when I get back to my office.

        I’m similar on spending patterns. Restaurants are probably our biggest exposure, or other cases where someone takes custody of the card and carries it to a back office, or records the number for any reason. There are usually backend controls, but it may take a while for bad employees to get caught.

      • Wyrd Smythe's avatar Wyrd Smythe

        I wouldn’t mind getting those emails. I’ll have to look into that. Thanks for the suggestion!

        So far, I’ve been okay at restaurants, but yeah, it’s one of the last places the card is out of your hands.

  • Mark Edward Jabbour's avatar Mark Edward Jabbour

    Hi Wyrd, Sorry for your loss. You can fight if that makes you happy. Who knows, your fantasy might come true. However, you don’t really have a case against BoA. But, you did have money stolen from you. A cyber crime I’m sure is quite common. What you need is a detective. Seems like you’re on the right track. However, to see it through will probably cost more in dollars, time, and aggravation than you’ve lost.

    Unless you like that sort of thing? Maybe you could start a service if you do. WS, PI, cyber crimes.

    Seems to me it could have been an inside job. Some bitter/resentful employee, with some company who has access to CC #s – working with some smart geek. Or, a random hacker. The more you buy online – the more likely it is that sooner or later you’ll be a victim. It’s the world we live in now. Take care.

    • Wyrd Smythe's avatar Wyrd Smythe

      Thanks. I dunno, though. I’ve certainly suffered damages, and if it can be shown it was due to their negligence, incompetence, or malfeasance, then maybe there’s a case? There are also some agencies (like the FTC) I could try without the cost of a lawyer. One friend suggested I just refuse to pay and take the credit hit because, at my age, who cares?

      I don’t buy much online and only from reputable sites, so who knows. For many years, I’ve only used that card online, so must have been one of those sites that leaked. I deleted my account on the one site I was slightly dubious about, though it appears legit.

      Heh, no, I have no desire to provide a detective service. Like reading the books; wouldn’t want to do it IRL.

      Did you watch the World Series? It worked out well from my POV. Teams I liked won, teams I didn’t lost. Yankees gone 0-3, Dodgers gone 0-4, and the Brewers take the trophy 4-1. Nice!

      • Mark Edward Jabbour's avatar Mark Edward Jabbour

        I did watch the Series. However, I’m a Yankees fan since the 50’s. Once a fan, always a fan. The first Series I remember was in 1958 – the Milwaukee Braves! versus the Yankees! We were living in France and listened on the Radio. Hank Aaron & Eddie Mathews for the Braves. NY won. My brother was always a Dodger fan, so I always hope for a Yankee/Dodger series. Anyway, good luck. It was a good playoff despite my favorites going out – badly.

      • Wyrd Smythe's avatar Wyrd Smythe

        You got that matchup in 2024! Dodgers haven’t done well in the WS: they’re 9-14. The Yankees, on the other hand, are 27-14, so they’ve won more than their fair share.

  • Katherine Wikoff's avatar Katherine Wikoff

    Good luck with this very frustrating situation. Wouldn’t it be nice if people just did their jobs the way they’re supposed to be done? And if other people weren’t criminals but were actually decent human beings instead?

    • Wyrd Smythe's avatar Wyrd Smythe

      Indeed. It very much taps into and aggravates key beliefs of mine. Firstly, that lying is a pretty big sin in my book. Secondly, as you say, doing your job as best you can. Hell of a reward for 26 years of being a good customer.

You must be logged in to post a comment.